The right to crack jokes or be rude
about homosexuals could fall victim to new government laws to stamp out
"homophobic" behaviour, Rowan Atkinson, the Blackadder star warned
yesterday.
Atkinson, who mounted a successful
campaign in 2004 to water down legislation aimed at criminalising
expressions of religious hatred, has returned to the fray to defend the
art of gay leg-pulling.
His concern is that Labour ministers are so obsessed with creating laws
to stop people being rude about each other that they are putting in
danger the right to free speech and, equally dear to his heart, the
comedian's craft.
In a letter to a newspaper he accused
ministers of filling their legislative programme with measures that
have "serious implications for freedom of speech, humour and creative
expression".
"Witness the fact that the Government
has invited two additional groups - the disabled and transsexuals - to
'make the case' for the proposed legislation to be extended to them.
"I am sure that they could make a
very good case, as indeed could all those who can claim that they
cannot help being the way they are. Men, for example, or women. Or
people with big ears."
Atkinson
added: "The devil, as always, will be in the detail but the casual ease
which some people move from finding something offensive to wishing to
declare it criminal - and are then able to find factions within
government to aid their ambitions - is truly depressing." (BPP: Well
said Rowan Atkinson!)
Jack Straw, the Justice Secretary,
has told MPs that such fears are unfounded because he will shortly
introduce an amendment to the Bill ensuring that cases can be pursued
only when the offending words are specifically intended to pose a
threat and are not merely humorous, mocking or abusive.
As with an eventual compromise deal
struck over the Religious Hatred Bill, there will also be a specific
clause to protect the right to freedom of speech.
Ministers have firmly dismissed as
unfounded claims that playground insults or jokes about gays could be
caught by the new offence.
Last night Chris Bryant, the openly
gay Labour MP, said Mr Atkinson should relax because the right to make
jokes about gays would remain. "I think it is perfectly possible to
create a distinction in law between incitement to hatred and having a
laugh," he said.
Lord Lester, the Liberal Democrat
peer who helped draft the compromise wording on the religious hatred
law, said it was clear that "politically incorrect jokes at the expense
of gay people" should not be banned.